Frontline Initiative on the NADSP Code of Ethics
Why not try?
I first met Paula back in 2013 when I started working at Aspire. Before that, I had never worked in health or human services, though I always knew I wanted to work with people. Growing up, my mom worked in nursing homes, and I often spent my summers volunteering there. Still, I had never encountered anyone quite like Paula.
The first time I interacted with someone who didn't use spoken language to communicate, I found myself speaking much louder than usual. A staff member training me kindly reminded me, "Just because they can't talk doesn't mean they can't hear." I felt embarrassed. Why had I assumed that those two things were connected? Looking back, it was one of my earliest lessons in how quickly we can make assumptions about someone's abilities without even realizing it.
Paula is all smiling as she gets ready to try adaptive water skiing.
Paula has profound intellectual disability. She does not communicate using spoken language and receives full support from her staff. When I first met her, I didn't know how to communicate with her. More importantly, I didn't yet understand how much she was already communicating with me.
While it’s true that I talked to Paula often, I didn't really talk with her. I always made sure to tell her what I was doing as I supported her and explained what was happening throughout her day. But I never just sat down and simply talked to her about life. If I asked Paula how her day was, she couldn't answer me with words. If I told her about my weekend, she couldn't tell me about hers. At the time, I didn't understand what a conversation could look like when only one of us used spoken language.
In those early days, there was an unspoken question that lingered in my mind, and sometimes in the minds of others: Why try? It wasn't because we didn't believe Paula was worth the effort. Instead, doubts would surface. Why offer an activity if we weren’t sure she would enjoy it? Why risk upsetting her with something new? Why attempt a conversation when she couldn't respond with words?
Our uncertainty could become a barrier of its own. By worrying so much about whether Paula would enjoy or understand the experience, we sometimes avoided offering her the opportunity to experience it at all.
Paula experiences the thrill of adaptive water skiing, one of the many adventures made possible by discovering what brings her joy.
I didn’t realize it then, but these questions revealed more about the limits of our understanding than they ever did about Paula.
Beginning to Understand How to Listen
Over the years Paula has been helping to clean part of her home with hand-over-hand assistance. She hasn’t been enthusiastic about this task and often expressed her displeasure through angry vocalization, letting us know she wasn't thrilled with the activity.
But there was one aspect of cleaning she seemed to enjoy: vacuuming. Whenever staff vacuumed, Paula would smile and laugh. This everyday task brought out a completely different reaction from her. She had been communicating with us all along, and we were beginning to understand how to listen.
Maybe the question shouldn't have been, "Why try?" but rather, "Why not try?" We needed to give Paula the chance to experience different things and allow her to express her feelings about them.
We started by asking one key question: What brings Paula joy?
Paula loves warmth, whether it's hot summer weather, being wrapped up in cozy clothes, or lying under a pile of soft blankets. She enjoys loud noises, including the sounds of vacuums, hair clippers, and lawn mowers. She has a deep love for all kinds of music, especially rock and roll.
Providing Paula with more opportunities didn't mean deciding for her what she should enjoy. It meant giving her the chance to experience something and then respecting her feedback.
These discoveries were wonderful, but we knew there had to be more. What else could we explore?
Trying New Activities
Then came an opportunity for adaptive water skiing. Why not give it a shot? I remember standing on the dock as Paula was transferred from her wheelchair, secured into a seat and harness on skis, and pulled by a boat across the lake, tears welling in my eyes. She was water skiing, and she seemed to love it!
This experience opened the door to Paula and her staff trying many new activities. She continues to participate in adaptive skiing whenever it is available. Paula also attended a local 5K race for several years. The race happened during the summer, with local law enforcement using their sirens at checkpoints along the route, which delighted Paula, who would smile and laugh at the sound. After her first year of attending the 5K, the officers began to recognize her and would lengthen the siren blasts as she passed by! Paula also attends dances, always claiming her favorite spot close to the speakers. During the COVID pandemic, she enjoyed virtual concerts.
The more we learned about Paula, the more opportunities we could offer her. With each new experience, Paula had another chance to share something about herself.
Of course, some things, like cleaning with hand-over-hand assistance, remained a firm "no" from Paula. Just as we learned to listen to her “yes,” we also learned to respect her “no.” Providing Paula with more opportunities didn't mean deciding for her what she should enjoy. It meant giving her the chance to experience something and then respecting her feedback.
Sasha and Paula enjoy some sunshine together during a nature walk.
As I learned how Paula communicated, I found myself helping others learn to communicate with her as well.
A family member who hadn't seen Paula in a while came to visit, bringing a gift: a soft blanket. Unknowingly, she had chosen the perfect gift.
However, when it came time to visit, she wasn't sure how to interact. She was uncertain about talking to someone who couldn't respond with words and asked me to stay. So, I did. I sat with them and helped bridge the conversation. When she was unsure of what to say, my advice was simple: "Just talk to her."
Talk about your life, what you've been doing, and ask her questions. Include her in the conversation. She may not respond with words, but that doesn't mean she isn't listening or that she has nothing to say.
Years earlier, I'd wondered why we should continue trying to talk to Paula when she couldn't respond with words. Now, I was sitting beside someone else, encouraging them to do exactly that.
Somewhere along the way, I stopped waiting for Paula to learn how to communicate with me and started learning how to communicate with Paula.
As we continued to learn more about Paula, we were able to support her in building a life rich with experiences, relationships, and things that brought her joy.
Perhaps one of the most meaningful experiences was when Paula, with help from her sister and staff, was able to reconnect with her mother after nearly 50 years apart. It's hard to express what such a reunion meant to Paula. But by then, we had learned that words weren't always necessary. We could simply be there, pay attention, and let Paula express herself in her own way.
As direct support professionals, we help people live meaningful lives. Yet, we can also fall into biases and preconceived notions because we are human.
As direct support professionals, we help people live meaningful lives. Yet, we can also fall into biases and preconceived notions because we are human. Sometimes these biases don't seem cruel or discriminatory; they might even seem reasonable. What if they don't like it? What if they don't understand? What if it upsets them? Why try?
But if we want to provide true equity and inclusion for the people we support, we must be willing to challenge these assumptions.
My advice to fellow DSPs is simple: Try. Try the activity. Offer the new experience. Have the conversation. Take the time to learn what brings someone joy and what causes discomfort. Learn their “yes” and learn their “no.” Don't assume that just because someone cannot communicate with words, they aren't communicating at all.
Sometimes, they're just waiting for us to learn how to listen.